Peer-Review Policy
GIJSR proposes to follow a double-anonymous peer-review system, in which reviewers and authors are not informed of one another's identities during review, wherever practicable. This approach aims to ensure impartial, objective, and fair evaluation of all manuscripts on the basis of scientific merit alone.
Manuscript Review Workflow
A transparent, step-by-step process from submission to publication.
Manuscript Submission
Author submits manuscript via the official submission channel. Submission confirmation is issued by the editorial office.
Initial Editorial Screening
The editor-in-chief or managing editor assesses the manuscript for suitability, scope alignment, and basic editorial requirements before proceeding to peer review.
Plagiarism & Ethics Assessment
The manuscript is screened for originality using plagiarism detection tools and assessed for adherence to ethical research standards.
Independent Peer Review
The manuscript is assigned to two or more subject-specialist reviewers who evaluate it for scientific rigour, methodology, originality, and scholarly contribution.
Editorial Decision
The editor collates reviewer feedback and communicates an initial editorial decision: Acceptance, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Rejection.
Author Revision (if required)
Authors are requested to revise their manuscript in response to reviewer comments and resubmit with a detailed point-by-point response.
Final Acceptance
The revised manuscript is reviewed for adequacy of revisions, and a final acceptance decision is communicated to the authors.
Copyediting & Publication
Accepted manuscripts undergo copyediting, typesetting, and proofreading before formal publication in the journal.
Editorial Decisions
Every manuscript receives a clearly communicated editorial decision based on reviewer feedback and editorial assessment.
Acceptance
The manuscript is accepted for publication as submitted or with only minor copyediting corrections.
Minor Revision
The manuscript requires minor revisions addressing specific reviewer or editorial comments before acceptance.
Major Revision
Substantial revisions are required, and the manuscript will undergo further peer review after resubmission.
Rejection
The manuscript does not meet the journal's requirements for scope, quality, or originality at this time.
Reviewer Responsibilities
All reviewers are expected to uphold the highest standards of scholarly integrity and professionalism.
- Maintain strict confidentiality regarding manuscript content and review details
- Provide objective, evidence-based, and constructive evaluations
- Declare any conflicts of interest prior to accepting a review assignment
- Complete the review within the agreed timeframe
- Avoid using unpublished research from reviewed manuscripts
- Recommend appropriate revisions or raise substantive scientific concerns
Become a Reviewer
GIJSR welcomes applications from qualified researchers and academics who wish to contribute to the peer review process. Reviewers play a vital role in maintaining scholarly quality and scientific integrity.